Monday, December 20, 2010

Dismissed.

No one ever said it was going to be easy.

I can't say I'm surprised. The writing was on the wall. The final and cumulative semester grades were just released a few minutes ago and not only am I not going to be able to progress to 3rd semester, I won't even have the chance to repeat 2nd. I was still studying up until the very end, hoping that I'd do well enough to repeat, but things haven't been looking good for at least the past 2 or 3 weeks.

Because of this (although I'm really bummed out) I'm not completely shocked. I wasn't anxiously awaiting for my grades because I knew it wasn't close. Also because of this, I've had a lot of time to think about what to do next. The way I see it I have 4 options that are attractive, all for different reasons, and a 5th option in which I have no interest:

  1. Appeal the dismissal in hopes of being able to return to Ross. - From what I understand, I should be receiving an email shortly which formally informs me that I've been dismissed (and not just an email that contains numbers). That email will have instructions on how to go about the appeals process. I also understand that successfully appealing a dismissal and being re-admitted into Ross is very rare. I don't expect to be able to return to Ross, but I'll go through the steps anyway. The worst they can say it 'no'.

  2. Inquire about admittance to AUC. - When I first applied to schools I only ever began the applications process for SGU and Ross. Since that time, knowing what I know now, (while giving advice to others) if I had to go to the applications process again, I'd apply to AUC as well. This option is also a long shot. I've already sent their admissions department an email, but they haven't replied yet. I plan on calling them in the next day or two just to ask some questions.

  3. Apply to AUA, MUA, and SMU. - This option took a while to accept this as a viable option. If you go back through this blog, I've always said that Ross was the last option for me and if it didn't work out I'd have to figure out what I really wanted to do with my life -- and that I wouldn't be applying to other schools. This isn't just about reputation or anything like that. Being from California, the ability to practice in California is a big deal to me. I've always said that while traveling the country, practicing in any number of states for the next 5, 10, or 15 years was appealing, I always saw myself returning and settling down back in California. And if I graduate from any of these schools, practicing in California isn't an option. But things have changed... Some people give "the dream." People have their reasons. I'm not really judging, it's just that everyone's different and you don't really know what you're going to do until you're put into this situation. Life goes on and you have to make a choice. In the past 2-3 weeks I've decided pretty concretely that this isn't the end. In the end, I really do want to be a doctor. I'm going to be inquiring and applying to AUA, MUA, and SMU (in that order) in the next couple weeks. From everything I've heard, out of the options I've listed so far, this is the most realistic option. The first 2 are long shots. It's common knowledge that dismissed students from Ross (and SGU and AUC) are easily admitted into these other schools. I'm almost 100% positive that I'm going to be accepted to one of these schools if I choose to pursue it.

  4. Give up medicine and start looking into international relief organizations. - Maybe I'm just not cut out to be a doctor. I believe I genuinely want to and I had the right attitude and drive for it and that I'm pursuing medicine for all the right reasons, but maybe I'm just not smart/studious enough and it's actually an impossible/unrealistic goal. After all, if just anyone could be a doctor, there would be a lot more doctors. I've lived on Dominica, on my own, for the past year. I've spent the entire year of 2010 on the island. I've also received so many thousands of dollars of loans and am in so many thousands of dollars in debt. And I've done all this with absolutely no promise of success. And I think when you (anyone) puts themselves in any situation where you have to take a leap of faith, without a safety net, in the face of absolute success or failure, you kind of learn things about yourself. Whether it be going to Ross in the pursuit of medicine or anything else in life, I think it's almost inevitable. I would guess that the majority of students at Ross think the same thing -- maybe not all -- but the majority. I've learned: (1) I absolutely don't get home sick, (2) the really do love learning medicine and the decision to pursue it was the right one, and (3) I enjoy traveling outside the US in order to work. In the past year I've done a relatively fair amount of inquiry into organizations like Doctors Without Borders. I've mentioned Doctors Without Borders in the past at least once or twice, but I didn't mention that I've already contacted some members and already had the chance to ask some preliminary questions. If I ever graduated, I had no doubt that joining one of those types of organizations for at least a couple years was one of my life goals. And those "couple of years" may have stretched out much farther, depending on the experience as a whole... But who says you have to help out as a doctor? If medicine really isn't for me who says you can't join one of those organizations anyway? They have all kinds of positions waiting to be filled.

  5. Nursing. - This is option 5 (a.k.a. the non-option) and have zero interest in this possibility. And when I say this, this isn't coming from with an attitude of "looking from up on high as a doctor, looking down at all the nurses." Remember, I spent my first couple years out of high school, trying to figure out what I wanted to do. While I was doing this, I was completing nursing pre-requisites at my local community college. I've had plenty of time to see nursing from an academic stand point and a practical one (working inside hospitals) and it's just not something I want to do. That was 8 years ago. But even now, in the face of having to make another decision, that route has little appeal to me.
For all intents and purposes, my life at Ross is over. I would say that "as soon as it started, it was over." But I can't say that because after being there for an entire year, I had plenty of opportunity to succeed and I didn't. I can't say that because it "didn't just start." I received my acceptance letter 2 year ago. It was 2008 and I was 26 years old. I'm 28 now and life definitely goes on. I'm a little older (and a little wiser?) but I figure I'm still young enough to give it one more go at one of these other schools. And if that doesn't work out, maybe I'll be joining Doctors Without Borders or Red Cross or any other of these types of organizations a little sooner than expected (and without some fancy initials next to my name).

So there you have it. Unless I get approved for a miracle appeal, the Ross Experiment is over.

And I think I'll end this blog here. I've always said that this blog would either be a written record of success or failure at Ross. That written record ends today. For all potential Ross students looking for information, read this blog for my advice, but I warn you now to consider the source.

Which ever one of the options I listed above comes true, I'll continue to record everything on a new blog I set up here:

Failing Out of Medical School: A First Hand Account

Thanks to everyone who's been following along and leaving comments all these years, but it looks like it's time for something new whether I like it or not.


-Jonathan

15 comments:

thuc huynh, md said...

my vote is for MUA. :)
keep at it and good luck!

thuc huynh, md said...

my vote is MUA.
keep at it and good luck!

C said...

Sorry to hear about your dismissal. Totally unsolicited advice, but I'd figure out what you'll do differently before re-applying to the other schools. It may be that a more supportive environment is all you need, but I'd also really closely examine your study skills and figure out where the weakness is. good luck!
Also, my email is shopaholicmd2013@gmail- I'm a second year at one of the SUNYs if you have any questions.

cb said...

I'm sorry, Jonathan.

Please don't discount nursing as a profession. There are nurses and there are "mega-nurses". I'm not as familiar with PA's although I've been treated by one.

There are so many positions in health care that are needed, a doctor is just one position of many.

I did not have the skills to be a nurse or a doctor, I'm smart, but not that kind of smart!

I ran a surgery center and hired and fired doctors, nurses, CRNA's, nurse practitioners with PhD's, and a lot of other people required to run the surgery center.

All of the professionals were smart and capable. The plus for advance practice nurses is that they do most of what a doctor does, without the risks and huge malpractice costs. The training is relatively short and you can pay back some loans and work with NGO organizations.

Best of Luck,

pabrocb

Kenny said...

Option 3 sounds more promising than the rest of it. PA is another thing worth to look into Jonathan. By the way did you happen to know anything about Joyce? she disappeared in a sudden. She didn't blog or post youtube videos anymore. Hope she was doing ok and proceed to rotation by now. Just a little worry about you two. Now I know where you are heading to but still no sign of Joyce anywhere. Pls let me know if you had anything on her. (I'm starting in january with new curriculum...wish me luck)

Kyla said...

I'm sorry! I know you saw it coming, but it still sucks.

You didn't mention PA school...that might be another option!

sherell said...

u can always look at the option of being an EMT

K said...

After following your first blog, then this one and now the next as a silent fly on your wall, I'm very happy I did because I have seen you mature, grow in many dimensions and despite all the challenges you have remained a kind and compassionate person. I don't know anything about other Carrib schools besides Ross and SGU but I take it if you really want to do it, then go for it. I heard there are also schools in Ireland and Canada and Australia that are similar to Ross and SGU in that they teach in English and they are pretty good. I also agree with C in that Ross didn't sound like a very supportive environment. Just my impression... Keep at it and you will be a great heathcare provider, whatever route you choose.

Andrea said...

ever consider being a paramedic?

CJ said...

Oh don't give up on med. As you know there is a big and beautiful world outside of California and a lot of people that desperately need a doctor. I'm studying at OUM (Samoa). Might be another option worth looking in to? They just got accredited (ie student loans for you!). I'm an Aussie though.

OK, take care.

Stranded said...

Sorry about the disappointment. Thanks for all the info--and honesty.
Good luck with whatever comes next!

Chris said...

Jonathan,

I'm bummed to hear things didn't work out at Ross. While I'm still puzzled how a smart guy like yourself, who seems to be working his butt off, fails, I encourage to avoid giving up on your dream of becoming a doctor. You clearly have the passion to do this and I think you would make an excellent physician. Too many doctors these days, especially residents, take this job for granted. They're poor attitudes reflect in their work and unfortunately patient care tends to suffer as a result. If you pursue this and succeed, you'll come appreciate the hard work it takes in taking care of patients. It'll prepare you well for the bullshit of working in healthcare and the rigors of residency. Don't look at this failure as a sign of incapability, but more as a means of reaffirming your dream.

Having said that, I strongly suggest exploring one of the other Carribean Medical schools. I'm currently in a university program in the northeast and we a couple graduates from AUA and MUA. I know you want to settle in Cali, and these other schools may not give you an opportunity to do that, I don't think that should deter you from pursuing this route (you could always practice in Arizona or Nevada!).

Again, medicine needs more people like you. Please don't give up!

Chris
- ps don't become a nurse! I have the utmost respect for what they do and the importance of their work beyond words. But it's a thankless job, you take orders from punk residents like me, and you have to clean poop.
- pps best of luck, i'll be following your adventures on your new blog

janitorialservis said...

Have you thought about Podiatric Medicine?

Mike S said...

as you can see the reason you did not get into a MD or DO school in the states is because you clearly do not have the work ethic as you have proved that or you're just stupid

Fariha_H said...

Hey Johnathan, sorry about your dismissal. I actually read your blog before applying to Ross and just realized we were in the same 2nd semester class. It was a really difficult semester. I hope things work out for you.
FH